Wednesday, May 03, 2006

Ecclesiastical transparency

One of the news stories about the major budget-cutting process by the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)'s General Assembly Council lifts up the tensions around a decision to close the meeting to a number of corresponding members and at-large members. Local readers who have been following the discussions about transparency in Tarentum's local government might find this an interesting article to read in order to see how issues of open government play out in an ecclesiastical context.

The PCUSA is not subject to any state's sunshine law, but has adopted its own open meetings policies. In each of the two policies, the Office of the Stated Clerk was given the responsibility for interpreting the rules. Interestingly, the stated clerk himself was excluded from the closed session of the GAC.

What was bad about the decision to close the meeting of the GAC: Representatives of groups from whom the church had decided it wanted to hear were excluded from deliberations on far-reaching matters. This goes to whether the ultimate decisions were made with the best wisdom and information available.

What was good about the process: The church at large and the public knew what the GAC was going to be doing in the closed session, and do not appear to have been surprised when the GAC came back into open session and announced its decisions on cutting the budget.

File under : , ,

Tuesday, May 02, 2006

I guess no one wears neckties any more

While I was in the New Kensington Kmart yesterday I checked out the prices of memory cards in the photography department. As I walked back into the rest of the store another customer planted herself in front of me.

She: Are you going to help her? [pointing at the Kmart associate working behind the photo developing counter]
Me: [after pausing to see that the associate did not seem to be having an emergency] I'm sorry, I don't work here.
She: But are you going to get someone to help her?
Me: Let me try again. I am not. A Kmart. Employee.
She: [long pause] Oh. I'm sorry.

If the reserved pastor thing doesn't work out for me, I know there are other possibilities. Jarod has nothing on me.

Maybe it's all because I once stayed at a Holiday Inn Express...

File under: ,

Monday, May 01, 2006

Portrait of the reserved pastor as a medieval warrior

During the past week I have been on vacation with my parents, my sisters and their families. Part of the vacation included going out to a dinner entertainment called Medieval Times.

crown.JPGWhen I arrived they gave me a crown to wear, addressed me as "M'Lord" and asked me to pose for a photo. So I went along with the program, wondering what possible use they might make of a photo of me in a hokey cardboard crown. Little did I know what they were going to do through the magic of editing a digital image.

The entertainment during dinner was a drama in an arena, acting out a medieval tournament to resolve a conflict in an 11th century kingdom. Without giving away too many spoilers for the story, it was one about chivalry, valor, betrayal, and the victory of good over evil. Our party and others in our section were supposed to cheer for the Black and White Knight, a serious, unsmiling fellow, competent as a knight, said to have been a priest. One of the six knights who had a cheering section was the secret love of the princess. The Green Knight was scripted to be unliked as a foreign mercenary and barbarian, but he performed throughout the tournament with charming energy and style.

I found it hard to follow the dialogue, but the story was simple enough. The horseriding was impressive and the swordplay was dramatic. The dinner was good basic food - chicken and ribs and half a potato - all served without silverware that had not been invented in the 11th century.

At the risk of inviting comments about my "dark side", and without further ado, here is the portrait promised in the title of this blog entry:
portrait of the reserved pastor as a medieval warrior

File under : ,

Thursday, April 27, 2006

Incorrect assignment of blame

Wednesday's Valley News Dispatch had an editorial criticizing the Tarentum Borough Council for the illegal use of executive session on April 17 (discussed here and here on this blog). The editorial points a finger of blame at the borough solicitor saying he "should have at least asked Newcomer why the session was needed before it started."

I don't see why the borough solicitor should have the responsibility of policing the meetings of the Council. If someone knows of such a responsibility in his job description, perhaps they can identify it to me.

Many people could have asked such a question. A member of the public, such as myself, could have asked. The press could have asked. Any member of the council, including its president, could have asked. The fact that the solicitor was the lawyer in the room does not in itself make him responsible for cross-examining the members of the council that employs him.

I would not be surprised if the borough solicitor heard the statement that the private meeting was for a "personal matter" as a denial that any borough business would be discussed. That was how I heard it. Then I was surprised later by the news that there had been an unrevealed purpose for the executive session. If no borough business had been discussed, the state Sunshine Act would not have had any application at all to the private meeting.

The public was misled. The responsibility rests with those who asked for the executive session without revealing to the public what they intended to discuss in private.

Update 05-02-06.

The Valley News Dispatch did not post this editorial on their website. While I was on vacation a friend emailed me a scan of the editorial, which I was not able to post to my blog at that time because of the lack of software I knew how to use. Although I take issue with one point in the editorial, it is well worth reading. Click the thumbnail image of the scanned editorial to see a readable version.


Saturday, April 22, 2006

AFK

In online lingo AFK is the abbreviation for Away From Keyboard.

Over the next week or so I am not going to be able to give much attention to the blog, and may not post much.

Comment moderation is on, but I won't be as prompt as in the past in reviewing submitted comments and making decisions about publishing them.

For those of you dying to make comments, please remember that I have raised concerns a number of times about people abusing anonymity. It does not take long to create a blogger account with a name that could consistently identify the person commenting. When you post comments you also have the possibility of choosing "Other" and typing in a name you want to use for the post. I simply don't have a lot of patience for people using their own anonymity to make numerous statements against individuals they name.

If you want to create a Blogger account, Blogger will offer you the chance to make your own blog. If you don't want your own, you can just close the window when you get to that point, and you will still have the Blogger account you created, complete with the possibility of a picture or logo (just edit your profile) that can appear on all your posts.

There are still many ethical issues around using pseudonyms. (Take a look at this for example.) But if you pick a name to use consistently, and no one else tries to put on the same mask, it is at least possible to have some kind of conversation.

Be patient while I'm AFK. I will get back to you.

Friday, April 21, 2006

Pittsburgh Presbytery meeting 04-06: 5. Vocational matters

Pittsburgh Presbytery handled the usual variety of vocational matters at its meeting on April 20, 2006 at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary.

Through the report of the Committee on Preparation for Ministry the Presbytery voted to receive five inquirers as candidates for the Ministry of Word and Sacrament: Caroline Becker (Hampton Presbyterian Church), Rebecca Cartus (Presbyterian Church of Coraopolis), Emily Miller (Southminster Presbyterian Church), Heather Tunney (East Liberty Presbyterian Church), and Tamara Yeager (Westminster Presbyterian Church).

Through the report of the Committee on Preparation for Ministry the Presbytery also approved Leslie Y. Boone (Mt. Pisgah Presbyterian Church) for ordination. Leslie will be a Chaplain for Medi Home Hospice.

Through the report of the Committee on ministry the Presbytery approved calls. My friend and colleague from New York state Dean Weaver has been called to be the pastor of the Memorial Park Presbyterian Church. Scott Hoffman has been called to be the associate pastor of the Presbyterian Church of Sewickley. Jay M. Hollinsworth has been called as pastor of the Swissvale Presbyterian Church.

God is constantly blessing the church by bringing people to new places and ways of service.

My other articles about this meeting: 1 2 3 4 5

File under : , ,

Pittsburgh Presbytery meeting 04-06: 4. Administrative Commission on Pittsburgh Presbyterian Foundation

During the meeting of Pittsburgh Presbytery on April 20, 2006 at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary the Presbytery dismissed with gratitude an administrative commission it had formed on December 1, 2005. That administrative commission had been formed to take oversight of the Pittsburgh Presbyterian Foundation.

The administrative commission presented a final report in which it identified some systemic problems in the Foundation, but at the same time acknowledged that the Presbytery had not been giving the Foundation the oversight and support that it needs.

The Commission issued a number of directives to restore a proper relationship between the Foundation and the Presbytery, and recommended that there should be a reexamination of the Foundation in two or three years.

My other articles about this meeting: 1 2 3 4 5

File under : , ,